The Southern Trust has been accused of engaging in a “possessive pursuit” to transfer services to Craigavon while creating “life and death risks” by relocating maternity from Daisy Hill Hospital in Newry.
And now the Daisy Hill Hospital Future Group – a partnership of concerned clinicians, political representatives, business organisations and community leaders in Newry, South Armagh and South Down – has unveiled a six-point plan for a potential alternative which it has presented to the Health Minister, Chief Medical Officer and Permanent Secretary.
The Southern Trust Board has endorsed the proposal of Trust management to relocate maternity services from Daisy Hill Hospital to Craigavon Area Hospital and to close all in-patient maternity services, with no more deliveries at Daisy Hill.
It is a move which is due to be implemented from Monday – despite the concerns of leaders in the border region about the safety risks for expectant mothers and their babies.
Dr Conor Patterson, President of Newry Chamber of Commerce and Chair of the Daisy Hill Future Group said: “While civic and political leaders in the east border region are all too aware of the many challenges facing our failing health and social care system, they are angry that Portadown-centric senior managers and clinicians in the Southern Trust do not seem to share their deep concern about the life and death risks that this decision now forces on expectant mothers and their families across Newry, South Down, South Armagh and the border counties in relation to time-critical access to maternity care.
“We believe that a powerful group within the Southern Trust has been seeking this relocation of maternity services for several years and that its lack of support during that time for the maternity unit at Daisy Hill, enabled by the apparent apathy of the Department of Health, ultimately led to the departure of three consultant obstetricians from Daisy Hill and to this crisis.
“Yet this obsessive pursuit of service transfer to Craigavon has already proven to be counter-productive, with the hospital now severely overstretched.
“Moving up to 1800 births from Newry to Craigavon risks not just destabilising Craigavon’s maternity unit, but will threaten also its ability to safely provide other acute medical services. It also presents an enormous challenge to the NI Ambulance service. Of the almost 1,800 mums who delivered babies at Daisy Hill, 96% made their own way there. Concern about the journey time to Craigavon is likely to significantly increase demand for emergency ambulance transfer from mothers-to-be in labour. This has the potential to crash a service already under severe pressure.
“To date, the Southern Trust has failed to share with any stakeholders its proposed safety plan to mitigate the obvious danger inherent in moving access to care so far away for so many of our mums-to-be.
“Have any of the measures contained in the proposed safety plan been stress-tested? What are NIAS’s considerations in relation to the role they will play in facilitating the move to Craigavon Area Hospital? Has the impact on Craigavon Area Hospital itself been properly assessed?
“We believe not and, for that reason, we support the Save Our Services group in its effort to secure a judicial review of the shambolic management of maternity care in our extensive border area by the Health Service, a decision on which is expected before the weekend.”
The Daisy Hill Future Group recently met with the Health Minister, the Permanent Secretary, the Chief Medical Officer and SPPG in relation to this issue, said Dr Patterson.
“We made it clear to them that the removal of maternity services from Daisy Hill was clinically and ethically wrong and had to be reversed,” he added.
“The Minister and Permanent Secretary accepted that Daisy Hill was suffering because of wider systemic problems with the way health services are organised in Northern Ireland. They said that this crisis would be the catalyst for reforming workforce planning, the failings of which they now accept account for a shortage of clinicians in a number of specialties in Northern Ireland.
“It is our view that this and the maternity crisis in the Southern Trust are symptomatic of a wider failure of vision and leadership by those responsible for health service planning.
“The Chief Medical Officer, Sir Michael McBride, and Permanent Secretary at the Department of Health, Mike Farrar, now have to engage in some bold and courageous decision-making. It is not too late if they act decisively (as the CMO and the service did during the pandemic). While Michael McBride and the Minister insist that this is a temporary reconfiguration to avert service closure, it would appear that the requisite actions to ensure the return of the service to Newry have not been initiated. They need to be!”
At the meeting with the health service leadership, the Daisy Hill Future Group presented a six-point plan to “safeguard maternity provision at Daisy Hill”, the “central plank” of which would be a commitment from the health service establishment to “properly incentivise obstetricians and gynaecologists to work in Daisy Hill, particularly in terms of the financial package on offer for full-time roles”.
“That package would have to take account of the real-world competition that our border region faces from the South in terms of the superior salaries and terms and conditions on offer there,” said Dr Patterson.
“A North/South dimension, involving collaboration with the Irish Government, would be transformational. Daisy Hill, located just a matter of a few hundred metres from the main north/south motorway and rail service, has enormous potential to become a centre for the provision of acute hospital services, including maternity services, to patients from north and south of the border, if the will is there.
“The impact of both governments prioritising investment in healthcare provision at Altnagelvin for mutual benefit shows what is possible. The Health Minister, Department of Health and the Southern Trust leadership must commit to this plan. A significant immediate step would be to require Craigavon-based clinicians to support services at Daisy Hill, as per their employment contracts.
“The five Health Trust model in the North does not work. Trusts compete with each other and seek to concentrate staff and resources where each of them are respectively headquartered, even when demography and clinical considerations do not justify it. This dynamic particularly disadvantages centres outside of the greater Belfast region, which de facto includes, as well as the Belfast Trust hospitals, Dundonald hospital and Craigavon and Antrim Area hospitals.
“What is needed is the establishment of a single employing authority for clinicians modelled on the PSNI and the NI Ambulance Service, which can deploy personnel to where the need is greatest as part of a regional service. Without such a change large areas of the North will be condemned to a stark inequality in healthcare provision, with serious human and economic consequences. It is this which is the structural change required in Northern Ireland, rather than the closure of clinical units despite clear evidence of patient safety risks in order to suit those who have a vested interest in concentrating activity and resources in Greater Belfast.
“Those responsible for providing a safe and modern health service, of which maternity is such a key part, to all citizens in Northern Ireland, must recognise that two thirds of our population do not live in Greater Belfast. As with the economy, regional balance is essential if the North is to thrive.
“The Daisy Hill Future Group will not stop in its determination to see maternity services restored and to ensure that the agreed capital investment and service development plans for Daisy Hill are delivered. Our community demands equality. Our expectant mothers have a right to access essential healthcare in their city, and we must insist that their rights and the rights of all our citizens are respected.”
