A Newry mum is asking why parents of children attending the EA Music Service were not consulted before the decision was made to almost immediately cease provided transportation.
Mum-of-three, Ciara Lavery has a daughter attending a brass instrument ensemble in the Portadown area, with rehearsals scheduled every Wednesday evening.
She says her daughter absolutely loves attending her music practice, enjoys the social aspect of meeting other children from areas across Northern Ireland and, likewise, thoroughly enjoys getting the bus to practice and spending time with her friends.
However on November 16, she, like many others, received an email that caused her immediate alarm. The email notified her that the bus service for EA Music would cease as of November 20.
This, she said, means her daughter will now be unable to attend her rehearsals.
Speaking to Armagh I, Ciara explained that the bus has been operational for as long as she can remember. Although she herself never used it, she knows of many other parents who would have taken the bus in their own school days to ensembles.
“It comes through Kilkeel, through Newry and heads on to Portadown,” said Ciara. “The stop where my daughter gets on also has a second bus which does collection and drop off because there are so many other areas where the ensembles take place.”
According to the EA Music Service website, there are a total of 21,802 pupils; 54 ensembles; 638 schools and 212 tutors all participating with the scheme across Northern Ireland.
The email sent to Ciara, by Darren Canmore, Head of EA Music explains that the bus service to 11 of the groups and ensembles will now no longer run.
It stated the reasons for the cessation of the service as “funding for this year is substantially below what is needed to sustain services, let alone meet rising need”.
However, Ciara said that the email came completely out of the blue and with no prior warning or consultation with parents. If there had of been some conversation with parents of pupils, she said she was sure an agreement could have been reached to provide some financial contribution.
“I understand with the price of petrol, diesel and everything else that costs are rising,” said Ciara. “But there was no warning of this. I’m sure parents would be willing to pay towards the transport if it meant children were able to be taken to and from their rehearsals. But we were never asked.”
Ciara did explain that parents do pay an annual fee for their children to be involved with the scheme. But again, she said there was no discussion about whether or not a marginal increase in this fee would have been acceptable to covering the cost of the bus service.
As a mother of two other children, additional clubs and weekly commitments mean she and her husband will be unable to bring their daughter the lengthy 45 minute commute from Newry to Portadown once a week.
Ciara said her daughter is “extremely upset” after being sadly informed that this Wednesday will therefore be her final night at rehearsals.
“Internally, I’m sure it has been discussed but I think it should have been put out to the parents of the children who avail of the service,” said Ciara. “You want to give them as many opportunities as pssoible and music is often brushed under the carpet.
“It’s unfair, it really is unfair and the children are the ones who are going to suffer in the long run.”
Ciara has already taken the issue to Newry and Armagh MLA, Liz Kimmins who she said agreed to highlight the issue with her colleagues in the Education Committee.
Raising further concerns for the cessation of the service, Ciara asked, “If the children can’t go to rehearsals, what happens to the tutors? What happens to the bus drivers who were providing the collections and drop-offs? It has a massive knock-on effect.”
She has also asked why, after years of running without any publicised issue and only a few months into the school year, has this decision only been taken now?
The email from EA Music expressed that there has been “ongoing efforts to reduce expenditure” and that the EA Board had made the “difficult decision to implement a number of further saving measures”, including discontinuing the bus service.
Parents are now being asked to arrange their own transportation for children to rehearsals and upcoming Christmas concerts.
Ciara says this will either see children unfortunately have to leave their groups or put parents under undue pressures to ensure their children can continue with their practice.
Armagh I has contacted EA for comment.