Keep up with Armagh i

Judge rejects bid to have Killylea crash injury charge dropped

Killylea Road colliision in Armagh

A man who admitted causing the deaths of Peter and Loughlin Devlin in a crash near Killylea must face a charge alleging he caused grievous bodily injury to Loughlin’s wife, after a judge rejected a defence application to have it dismissed.

Ivan Petrov, 33, of Newry Road, Armagh, appeared at Newry Crown Court, where His Honour Judge Paul Ramsey ruled on Friday that there was sufficient evidence for the charge to proceed.

The application, which was outlined to the judge on Thursday, related to the allegation that Petrov caused grievous bodily injury to Shauna Devlin by driving dangerously on Killylea Road.

Defence counsel John Kearney KC argued that while the defence did not dispute Mrs Devlin had suffered injuries, they did not meet the legal threshold for grievous bodily injury. Prosecutor Charles MacCreanor made opposing submissions, setting out the extent of her injuries and the impact they had on her lengthy recovery.

In his ruling, Judge Ramsey said the court had to consider whether the prosecution evidence was sufficient to justify putting Petrov on trial for the charge.

He said the assessment of whether injuries amounted to grievous bodily injury could take account of “the severity and permanence of the injury, the age and health of the victim, the cumulative effect of multiple injuries, and the requirement for medical treatment and its extent”.

The judge added: “The courts have held that injuries do not need to be life-threatening, dangerous, or permanent to constitute grievous bodily injury.”

He said he had considered the evidence and the arguments made by counsel, and had to take the prosecution case “at its height”.

“I am satisfied the evidence discloses a case sufficient to justify putting the accused on trial in respect of count five,” Judge Ramsey ruled. “Accordingly, I reject the defence application.”

The ruling means Petrov must be arraigned on the charge. The case was listed for a further hearing next Wednesday, when Petrov is to be produced to the court in person.

Petrov appeared before the court in October and pleaded guilty to the charges relating to the deaths of Peter and Loughlin Devlin, and to causing grievous bodily injury to Ursula Devlin and Loughlin’s infant child. He had entered a not guilty plea to the charge concerning Shauna Devlin.

At that hearing, Mr Kearney described the challenge to that count as a “technical lawyering challenge”, saying it concerned whether the grievous bodily injury threshold had been met.

The charges relate to a collision on the outskirts of Killylea on December 27, 2024.

When the guilty pleas were entered, Judge Ramsey said he hoped they would give the family “some degree of closure” and that he wanted to sentence the case as soon as possible. He also said victim impact statements from the Devlin family would be sought ahead of sentencing.

Local jobs

Sign Up To Our Newsletter

Most read today

More in Killylea