The PSNI has responded to enquiries following the publication of a damning Police Ombudsman report into the misconduct of two officers, known as A and B, who abused their position for sexual purposes (APSP) when dealing with highly vulnerable people.
However, the response stopped short of backing mandatory referral to the UK-wide Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS), which comes under the remit of the Home Office, instead pointing to exclusions limited to working for other police forces.
Former PSNI specialist officer Nuala Lappin has called for officers who committed APSP to be treated the same as any person in a position of trust, including care staff, teachers, coaches and all professions involving contact with vulnerable individuals.
She said: “If such misconduct remains locked away rather than passed to the DBS, the safeguarding net fails when needed most. The Safeguarding Vulnerable Groups (NI) 2007 empowers and in many cases requires employers to refer dismissed staff to the DBS when their conduct shows risk. Crucially, a criminal conviction is not necessary. Public confidence demands nothing less than full transparency that every safeguard available has been triggered.”
Both Officers A and B were dismissed, but the PPS declined to prosecute, sparking a public backlash.
Under Northern Ireland law, causing or allowing harm to a vulnerable adult is a crime, and aggravating factors considered at sentencing include the offender being in a position of trust and the offence being committed by a public official in the course of their duties – both of which apply to police officers.
A number of victims of APSP, including some who have not yet reported to the Ombudsman, were dismayed and discouraged by the decision not to prosecute, with no meaningful consequences for the perpetrator.
Challenged on this, particularly given clear evidence of video footage that the officers not only filmed but shared, the PPS later confirmed the decision not to prosecute is being reviewed.
The PSNI was asked what consideration had been given to the outworkings of no prosecution, whereby those involved may seek to work or engage in activities and careers outside policing that involve vulnerable individuals.
The PSNI was also asked to examine its policies, particularly in terms of the current EVAWG strategies and public protection, and set out measures to be taken to address such behaviour and mitigate risks.
A spokesperson replied: “APSP is wholly unacceptable. It’s a serious breach of trust which can cause significant harm to victims and undermine public confidence. Decisions on whether to prosecute are, however, for the independent PPS. The investigation files were submitted by the Ombudsman, which is responsible for investigating such allegations. It would therefore not be appropriate for PSNI to comment on, or seek to influence, prosecutorial decisions.
“A decision not to prosecute does not lessen the seriousness with which PSNI regards APSP, nor does it prevent appropriate consideration of misconduct, safeguarding, vetting and risk management where the relevant thresholds are met.
“PSNI commissioned and completed Operation RORIC, a substantial review of historical investigations concerning sexual misconduct. It reviewed 154 investigations involving 134 officers and produced 183 recommendations covering investigative standards, intelligence and information sharing, victim-centred practice, systems, governance, supervision and training. All recommendations have been implemented. Improvements include strengthened investigative and supervisory arrangements; improved recording, intelligence-sharing and warning markers; enhanced safeguarding and victim-information processes; clearer oversight of duty status; and the removal of inappropriate streamlined disposals in sexual-allegation cases involving serving officers.
“The Service also commissioned the Langdale Review, which examined PSNI’s operational response to EVAWG, including sexism, misogyny and the effectiveness of professional standards processes. PSNI has delivered all recommendations and continues working with the Department of Justice to implement recommendations requiring regulatory changes.”
However, it was the breadth of barring procedures where PSNI pulled up short.
The spokesperson said: “PSNI is working with the Department on changes to the Police Misconduct Regulations, including provision for former members to be subject to misconduct proceedings and creation of barred and advisory lists. These measures would prevent dismissed officers from applying for future policing roles.”
Nuala, however, believes the proposed barring scheme doesn’t go far enough.
“Officers A and B are free to seek employment in any role, including within the care sector, in spite of the serious risk they pose. Only the Chief Constable’s discretionary referral power and legislative reform can and must close the door on these former officers and others displaying similar behaviours from ever working with vulnerable people again.”