Plans to refurbish a Grade B1-listed property on The Mall in Armagh and add a two-bedroom extension have been recommended for approval, despite dozens of objections from nearby residents.
An extension is going to be built at the back of 7 Hartford Place to provide an additional two bedrooms, and plans for a lounge and dining facilities have been approved as well, along with associated site works and repair works to the existing garage.
Two separate applications had to be lodged as the property is a listed building. Both the planning application and Listed Building Consent application were lodged by Weir + Weir Architects Ltd, Portadown, on behalf of Mr and Mrs Coote, Woodford Drive, Armagh.
The planning applications were listed for determination at the November meeting of the ABC Planning & Regulatory Services committee.
Planning Manager, Kyle Elder told committee members: “These planning applications seek full planning permission and Listed Building Consent for the change of use of an existing dwelling house to a guesthouse providing four bedrooms, with the erection of an extension to accommodate an additional two bedrooms and support accommodation.
“So, the guesthouse will provide a total of six bedrooms, with associated works to provide a lounge and dining facilities. Both applications are recommended for approval.
“With regards to the principle of development, officers are of the opinion that the proposed development accords with the provisions of the Armagh Area Plan, the SPPS and PPS 16, and therefore the proposal to develop the site for the purposes of a guesthouse is considered acceptable in principle.
“The development includes an extension to the rear and restoration works to the building and an outbuilding.
“In relation to the design layout, officers are of the opinion that there would be no unacceptable adverse effect on existing dwellings in terms of overlooking, loss of light, overshadowing, noise or other disturbance.
“7 Hartford Place is a Grade B1 listed building. Officers, in considering the application, have had special regard to and considerable weight to the desirability of preserving the building, its setting and any features of special architectural or historic interest it possesses.
“In relation to built heritage, officers are content that the proposed development complies with the SPPS and the policy provisions of PPS 6.
“The proposal does not propose any in-curtilage parking provision. The agent has identified parking available locally on the street and in public car parks. DfI Roads have raised no objections to this arrangement.
“Officers raise no concerns in relation to natural heritage, flood risk and drainage or sewage, with the relevant consultees on these matters raising no concerns either.
“In relation to the full planning application, 58 letters of objection from 17 postal addresses have been received. Regarding the listed building consent application, 44 letters of objection from 13 postal addresses have been received. All objection reasons have been fully considered within the report.
“Overall, officers consider the proposal to comply with Armagh Area Plan 2004, the policy requirements of the SPPS and all other relevant planning policies. On that basis, approval is recommended.
“The site’s located at 7 Hartford Place, which fronts onto The Mall. It’s located on The Mall East. You have the main building which fronts onto The Mall and then an elongated garden to the rear. At the north-east of the garden then is a greenhouse and some garages.
“The extension is to the rear of the dwelling. Some repair works are proposed to the front elevation, but there’s no substantial change to the front elevation of the building.”
Director at Weir + Weir Architects, Uel Weir explained that the proposed refurbishment scheme would be in keeping with the listed character of the property and its prestigious location on The Mall.
He commented: “I’m pleased to have with me Mr and Mrs Coote, who have put a fortune of money into this project and are itching to get going ahead.
“Quite honestly, if they don’t get going ahead, it will pop up somewhere else, but as a beautiful setting facing The Mall, it really is one of the heyday houses of Armagh and a great opportunity to create a five-star guesthouse of the highest quality, adding to the tourism mix of the city and enhancing the tourism offer.
“For goodness’ sake, get this thing into Armagh. Don’t lose it. Thank you.”
Armagh councillor, Scott Armstrong (DUP) spoke very positively of the conversion scheme, commenting: “I used to walk past this every day on my way to school and still enjoy walking around The Mall and seeing the beautiful architecture.
“This here obviously seems like a positive contribution to Armagh City. As somebody who sits on Economic Development, we do often talk about bed spaces within Armagh City, especially when we come up to Georgian Day and big events around the borough.
“We have a lack of bed space. Hopefully this can move that in the right direction. And I’m willing to say that this would be a great addition to The Mall going forward.”
Alderman Gordon Kennedy (UUP, Cusher DEA) welcomed the plans as well, commenting: “It’s good to see a building that had been lying vacant getting a bit of a spice-up and getting it back into circulation again. As Councillor Armstrong says, there is a lack of overnight-stay accommodation in the city, so hopefully this will help alleviate that slightly.”
As the property is a listed building, planning approval and Listed Building Consent had to be sought separately.
Councillor Scott Armstrong proposed planning permission for both, with Alderman Kennedy seconding the proposal.