Keep up with Armagh i

5G mast for Newry Road in Armagh wins approval on appeal despite neighbour and council objections

Overturning ABC Council's decision last year to refuse permission, the Planning Appeals Commissioner concluded: 'Should a link between harmful development and the devaluation of properties exist, I have not been provided with evidence that such an outcome would arise in this particular context'

Proposed Armagh 5G mast

Controversial plans to site a 5G phone mast beside the PSNI Station at Newry Road in Armagh have now been given the go-ahead after an earlier decision to refuse permission was overturned on appeal.

Armagh City, Banbridge and Craigavon Borough Council turned down the application by Cornerstone to install new apparatus on the site last summer.

But within a matter of months, the applicant challenged the decision through an official submission to Northern Ireland’s Planning Appeals Commission.

And now the Commission has upheld Cornerstone’s position and issued full planning approval to proceed – subject to a number of conditions.

The proposals relate to the lands currently housing the BT Exchange – between the PSNI station and Armagh City Hotel – with the applicants described in the original application as the UK’s “leading mobile infrastructure services company”.

Within the grounds of the PSNI station, there is already an existing lattice mast approximately 40 metres in height.

In all, 13 letters of objection from eight postal addresses were received in relation to the application.

Among other things, objectors argued that there was no evidence that the height of the new structure was necessary for communication purposes or otherwise, or that benefits would be provided in the locality which could not be achieved by other means.

They insisted there were no difficulties with broadband in the locality, and that the height of the proposed structure was considerably greater than the existing mast and therefore incompatible with the character of the surrounding landscape and visual amenities of the area, such as the County Armagh Golf Club and Palace Demesne.

They also flagged the visual impact on neighbouring properties and the potential devaluation of properties.

Visual impacts were cited regularly in the objections as “an additional eyesore”.

The plans were first submitted in July 2022 and subsequently amended.

The proposal sought to remove the existing rooftop telecommunications equipment and associated development. A new 25-metre lattice tower was to be constructed in its place, which would include six antennae and associated works.

A supporting statement in 2024 said the site at the BT Exchange in Armagh had an “important role to play in serving users in the centre and south of the city”.

But it added: “Whilst the site is strategically placed within the target area, it is in need of an equipment upgrade to ensure it can meet the increasing demands being placed on it. The existing rooftop equipment is not structurally capable of supporting the new equipment that would be required at the height necessary. As a result, the existing equipment needs to be removed and a new site developed.

“The volume of telecoms traffic that visits this area, whether for commercial, educational, residential or short-term purposes, is impacting the service provision for all users.

“The existing network needs to be strengthened. From a technical point of view, the location of the existing site is ideal, and it serves the target area well; for this reason, it is proposed that the new site will be within the grounds of the BT Exchange. The new site will serve O2 and Vodafone users.”

Despite Cornerstone advocating the need for updated equipment, planning officials recommended that the application be rejected and, after lengthy debate at the planning committee in July last year, it was refused.

But Commissioner Hannah Ellison, having considered the application afresh and visited the intended location, has now ruled in favour of Cornerstone.

She noted that ABC Council’s reference to policy relating to ‘New Development in a Conservation Area’ was “not applicable” in this appeal.

Commissioner Ellison found that the proposed site was “outside, but within close proximity to the Armagh Conservation Area” and added: “The council’s concerns focus on the effect of the proposed development on visual amenity and, in turn, on views out of the ACA. It has highlighted four viewpoints from which the proposal would be seen and from which it alludes harm would arise.”

Having considered each of the four, she rejected the arguments.

In relation to the view when travelling along Scotch Street on the approach to both junctions at Friary Road, as well as when at both junctions, much of the proposed mast, she considered, would be screened by the existing trees, the police building and “substantial fencing around it”.

“Only a limited amount of the uppermost part of the mast would be visible and it would have a relatively slender profile,” added Commissioner Ellison. “Furthermore, the foreground is dominated by the extensive road infrastructure which consists of several lanes of traffic meeting at this intersection, car parking, street lighting columns and signage.

“The utilitarian appearance of the proposal would not be a prominent or stark feature, but rather it would be read with and integrate cohesively into this modern and urban street scene.”

The Commissioner said ABC Council had not explained why the viewpoints it had identified were important in respect of the Armagh Conservation Area, why they should be protected or retained, “nor if or how they contribute towards the significance of the ACA”.

“The appeal proposal would be read in association with the modern streetscene in the foreground and, not only is it a considerable distance from the edge of the ACA, but the viewpoints do not contain features which make a contribution towards the significance of the ACA,” she found.

Overall, whilst the appeal development would be “visible from various viewpoints”, it “would not result in unacceptable damage to the visual amenity of the area”.

In terms of concerns raised by neighbours to the proposed mast, Commissioner Ellison did not believe the proposals would impact on the value of properties as some had argued when originally objecting.

“I acknowledge that residential properties are located nearby on Newry Road and that the proposed mast would be in the line of sight from main habitable rooms and gardens of the nearest properties,” she added.

But she continued: “Whilst this would result in a change in outlook for occupiers, I am satisfied that by virtue of the distance between the dwellings and the development, the intervening Golf Club car park and the mature vegetation, the proposal would not have a harmful effect on the living conditions of occupiers.

“Third parties have also drawn my attention to international research on the effect of development on the value of properties. Should a link between harmful development and the devaluation of properties exist, I have not been provided with evidence that such an outcome would arise in this particular context.

“Moreover, as I have found that the proposal would not result in harm, this matter is not determining.”

In granting approval, the Commissioner ruled: “The council has not sustained its reasons for refusal and the third party concerns do not persuade me that any other harm would arise. Therefore, the appeal shall succeed.”

Three conditions were, however, imposed – that the lattice be “unpainted and remain in its galvanised state in perpetuity”, that all equipment be removed from the site within six months if the site and equipment are no longer required, and that work should begin within five years of the permission now granted.

Local jobs

Sign Up To Our Newsletter

Most read today

More in Armagh